Read Our Reviews from Top Rated Dealer In Grove City, OH

Nila Smith

05/23/2026

5.00

S Montgomery

05/16/2026

5.00

Chip was awesome! Got us into a nice, clean, reliable car for a good price. Thank you!

Bill Antoniak

05/15/2026

5.00

Those guys are fantastic! Great deals on great cars!

Missy Eldred

05/13/2026

5.00

Thanks to Kelly and Tyler I'm an new owner of a Honda ru-v

Anthony Foster

05/12/2026

5.00

Modern Goddess

05/06/2026

5.00

Got my first car from here 10 years ago, and remembered how they worked with me and got me in a car. So, I bought my mom here and they were able to get her approved and in her new truck! 10/10, definitely recommend!

Alisia Shriver

05/04/2026

5.00

Izzy and tanner helped make my experience great! Customer service skills are great.

Marcus Evans

05/02/2026

5.00

Awesome people to work with! Good selection of cars to choose from with reasonable prices. Very recommended and will definitely buy from them again.

Zachary Cheesman

04/28/2026

5.00

Great customer service! I have horrible credit and they made my transaction seemingly easy. I recommend Tyler for selling you a great vehicle!

Buggs The Trucker

04/27/2026

5.00

Walked in to take a look at a Lincoln. Tyler showed the vehicle and told me the price. I was shocked. Great vehicle, very reasonably priced. Tanner worked diligently to get bank approval and was successful. I drove off with the vehicle same day. Very great place of business.

kennedy marshall

04/25/2026

5.00

Tanner and Izzy were awesome and great help !

Gabriel Matinez

04/25/2026

5.00

Was in and out with a new car! Great deal! And very nice people! Thank so much! Tylor did a great job!

Patricia Grossman

04/23/2026

5.00

I have never done a pay here pay here used cars but my family told me about this place and I tried it Chip and Tanner along with Tanner father is the best to work with. They are nice respectful and try really hard to get you in a vehicle. I love my car from them. I'll go back and get my kids a car from them!!! So be expecting me to come back and get more vehicles from you for sure! I love this place!!!! By: Grossman's

Terriona Jordan

04/23/2026

5.00

Izzy and Tanner were an amazing help, friendly honest and really have your best interest I won’t be going anywhere else !

Timi Spafford

04/20/2026

5.00

Izzy an Kelly was the best. I will refer them for a car. I live them they made my day f9rse when I was denied for other place.

Tabitha Deal

04/18/2026

5.00

They were wonderful we have about five cars for them so far they're amazing to work with they will work with your budget and with your down payment very pleased and very happy Tanner is number one tier. And also thank you guys for everything guys are amazing

Mike Gibson

04/18/2026

5.00

Izzy and Kelly were great. Easy process, very friendly.

Samuel M

04/15/2026

5.00

Izzy and tanner were great to work with! Got me in and out quick hassle free pleasure to work with them!

John Mason

04/10/2026

5.00

This was really quick and a nice fair deal for a nice vehicle! Tanner and Izzy took great care of us!

Brayden Southers

04/09/2026

5.00

amazing service izzy was awesome!!!!

Holly Burks

04/08/2026

5.00

My husband and I were searching for a red Chevy cargo van, we discovered one at Columbus Auto Resale. Made a phone call for a test drive. The van was ready and waiting.What a fabulous purchasing experience this was!Tyler, Tanner and the owner were very friendly, answered any questions that we had. Provided us with the Carfax print out.Very smooth and easy transaction of the sale!In all of our years of buying a vehicle, this was the most enjoyable. No hassle, no pressure and no BS.We highly recommend Columbus Car Resale!Customers for life!

Monica Goodwin

04/04/2026

5.00

Loved everything about this experience! From Izzy being a boss babe to Kelly being the most chill and professional salesman ever! I will definitely be back for my next car. They were all amazing, even got a new duck for my jeep from Chip…free of cost!

Katelynn “katelynn” Cooper

04/03/2026

5.00

Chip helped me today. walked off the lot with a 2014 ford fusion. absolutely love it!

faerygutz

04/03/2026

5.00

Chip was a great help!! :)

Ulizes Ruiz

04/03/2026

5.00

Had an amazing experience overall at this place. The salesperson Chip especially helped me as he did everything he could to get me a great deal on the car!

Thomas Potter

04/02/2026

5.00

Needed a vehicle, but didn't want to go to a large dealership. Based on friends buying here in past, I checked out and they had what I was looking for. Tanner was able to get me an overall great deal, and I was able to stay within my budget. I would and will recommend them to anyone I hear looking for a vehicle.

Abe G

04/02/2026

5.00

Bree Reedus

03/31/2026

5.00

Iizzy and tanner were wonderful and extremely helpful with me and my grandma if your looking for a good car and helpful service come here

Rilee Taynor

03/31/2026

5.00

tanner and izzy helped me get a car when no one else would!

Shelley Smith

03/30/2026

5.00

We walked into C.A.R with no expectations of leaving with a vehicle. We were just gonna test drive some and see what we liked. I was in an accident on Friday Feb 13th and my truck was totalled, that was the only car our family had so to say we needed one was an understatement. We walk onto the lot and out comes the friendliest funniest man named Chip. Chip was beyond helpful. Took my husband's ID and said which ones you wanna try? We drove several cars that day and fell completely in love with this Honda Odyssey. To say the staff at Columbus Auto Resales is helpful is an understatement. Chip and Tanner went Above and beyond this past Saturday! They worked with us to send us home that day with a safe reliable vehicle for my family and for that Thank you just doesn't seem sufficient! If you are looking for a used vehicle I'm telling you stop looking now this is the place. Do yourself a favor and ask for Chip but I'm not responsible for your belly hurting from all the laughing! Thank you Chip and Tanner and all the CAR team. The Smith family couldn't be happier.

Taylia Dixon

03/28/2026

5.00

I want to say Tanner and Izzy are amazing and thank you for best great people and even better salesmen and woman

Jami M

03/28/2026

5.00

💣 T AND T 💣>>>Tyler and tanner were amazing! My husband and I bought an awesome car for our daughter! She’s gonna be so happy!! Thank you y’all!!

Crystal Nethers

03/28/2026

5.00

Isamar and tanner did great

Ksioshd Iehwheh

03/26/2026

5.00

Izzy and tanner are the best people I’ve ever met in my entire life. 5 stars

keith blankenship

03/23/2026

5.00

Spacelucy

03/21/2026

5.00

Izzy and Tyler were awesome they were quick and very helpful! If you need a car ask for Izzy!

John Chappell

03/20/2026

5.00

Izzy and Tanner and Tyler over at Columbus Auto Resale inc are the best, I am a more than satisfied customer. They definitely got the hook up over in Grove Ciry 🫶🏼

Aiden Richardson

03/20/2026

5.00

Wonderful experience, chip, Tyler and tanner proved they could job done.

Iesha Peden

03/18/2026

5.00

Izzy was amazing Kelly was a great help

paul chambers

03/16/2026

5.00

Amazing car lot ! Second car I’ve bought in 2 years so far no issues , Kelly and Tyler will get you in and out quick and keep you in the price range you ask! Couldn’t ask for a better place to be able to go to get me a car

Shannon Hickey

03/16/2026

5.00

Tyler and tanner are great

Lacie Mountain

03/14/2026

5.00

I had an amazing experience at Columbus Auto Resale! From the moment I walked in, I felt welcomed and taken care of.Working with Kelly and Izzy was truly the highlight of my experience. Izzy was absolutely amazing—she went out of her way to make my children feel welcome and comfortable while supporting me through the entire car-buying process. As a mom, that meant a lot and made the experience so much easier and more enjoyable.Kelly, the owner, is hands down one of the most genuine people I’ve met in the car business. He gave me a great deal and treated me like family rather than just another transaction. That level of honesty and kindness is rare these days.If you’re looking for a dealership that truly cares about their customers, I highly recommend Columbus Auto Resale. I will most definitely be returning in the future!

khristian Long

03/14/2026

5.00

Great service, great people. Worked with my bad credit and got me approved with the best vehicle on the lot. Izzy and Kelly are the go to!

Shay Smith

03/11/2026

4.00

Dylan Hayes

03/07/2026

5.00

Best in town

Jenilee Zuver

03/02/2026

5.00

Izzy and Kelly were amazing with my trade in and deal on my new car! Was a quick and easy process! Thank you again!!

Ikia Hill

02/28/2026

5.00

Izzy and Tanner hooked me up with a nice 2010 Honda Civic Today!! Thanks so much!!!

Devin Chapman

02/28/2026

5.00

Izzy and tanner were the best to work with!!! It was a very comfortable and enjoyable place to be. They take very good care of you

Anthony Amburgey

02/27/2026

5.00

Appreciate you Kelly

Ashley Perdue

02/24/2026

5.00

Had a wonderful experience thy got me taken care of as soon as I walked in the door. Tanner did amazing